adcount=1;
"A cruel debate opponent" "Pagan blasphemer" "Reverse-iconoclast" "don't get pissed at him b/c he pwn yalls whiney asses"
My Photo
Name:
Location: Indiana, United States

Miscellaneous meanderings and philosophical ramblings. The title from a spiral notebook I used to jot down my thoughts on religion and other matters some years ago. I like to write, think and express my views on various issues. Robust discussion is welcome.


Chris of Rights and Charles Martin <-- Lists of debunked Sarah Palin rumors

"Lan astaslem."
I will not submit. I will not surrender.

Saturday, January 05, 2008

Did Brian Cutler and Kelly O'Connor say Richard Dawkins had an affair?


Brian and Kelly being core members of the (ir)Rational Response Squad. According to another atheist going by the name Reed Braden, they claimed that Richard Dawkins had an affair of some kind. This is a rather odd situation considering that the (ir)Rational Response Squad has been riding Dawkins' coat tails for awhile now. If it's true that they did make the claim, it provides more evidence of the self-serving immaturity that typifies the core/founding members of this fundie atheist group.

Before preceding let's get something out of the way. Does it matter if Dawkins had an affair? For me, as a Christian, it matters not with regard to his arguments, as they need to be addressed directly, and that is not accomplished by referring to something like this. In other words, let's reject the lazy ad hominem fallacy temptation.

The sordid events, with several updates already, are being tracked here. (profanity alert)

As to why the (ir)rationals would float something like this about Richard Dawkins, according to Reed:

RDF's* new management stopped RRS from having contact with Richard and RRS wants the lady in charge fired... so they made up an allegation of an affair.

[* - Richard Dawkins Foundation]

If a substantial portion of this turns out to be true, it may be the final nail in the (ir)Rational Response Squad coffin, or at least another nail much closer to that. If it's a false claim against Brian and Kelly, than Reed, whoever he is, has much explaining to do and will no doubt be facing a lawsuit over the matter and appropriately so.

But as noted, if it is true, not only is this another nail added to the coffin, there is the sweet irony of a well-known atheist like Dawkins, who has his own fundie tendencies, being the one to pound the nail home.

For some reason I have a desire for popcorn right now.

---

Filed under: Religion -- 4GrinsNGiggles -- News

Trackposted to: Stop the ACLU, Outside the Beltway, The Virtuous Republic, Is It Just Me?, The Midnight Sun, Rosemary's Thoughts, Stix Blog, Right Truth, DragonLady's World, Shadowscope, Stuck On Stupid, Leaning Straight Up, The Amboy Times, Chuck Adkins, Adeline and Hazel, Pursuing Holiness, third world county, Woman Honor Thyself, The Uncooperative Blogger, DragonLady's World, Pirate's Cove, Celebrity Smack, The Pink Flamingo, Right Voices, Stageleft, Church and State, Right Pundits, Blog @ MoreWhat.com, guerrilla radio, Adam's Blog, Cao's Blog, Big Dog's Weblog, Phastidio.net, Conservative Cat, Nuke's, Allie is Wired, Faultline USA, The Crazy Rants of Samantha Burns, The World According to Carl, Blue Star Chronicles, Gulf Coast Hurricane Tracker, and The Yankee Sailor, thanks to Linkfest Haven Deluxe.

Trackback URI                             Submit this post on Digg.com! width=                     View blog reactions

Monday, May 07, 2007

I'm soooo impressed


Christians debate Atheists on ABC this Wednesday. Pardon my *yawn* but the participants on either side are not really upper tier when it comes to defending or presenting their case.

On the Christian side we have Ray Comfort of bananarama fame and Kirk Cameron, someone who is certainly not famous for his theological work or apologetic skills. On the side of the atheism, we have Brian Sapient and his girlfriend Kelly, both hailing from the online atheist group/Internet radio program Rational Response Squad.

As for the bananarama quip, Comfort at one time argued against evolution by referring to the design of a banana (scroll down). Yes, I rolled my eyes the first time I heard about that. He has since stated it was mostly tongue in cheek but a video of him making this "argument" with the banana has gotten around the Internet, with much derision being the natural result. Good job there buddy. Hopefully He didn't waste his time bringing that up again in the debate.

Regarding the (ir)rationals, as I prefer to call them, they're not known for presenting sound scholarship (see here) or reasoned debate, to put it politely. When one states that religion is a mind f**k, or that Christians are Christarded, as The Sap has, it's no wonder that other atheists are bothered by the media choosing to highlight this group . Along with such extreme rhetoric, The Sap tends to immediately accuse Christians of being liars when we've merely made a simple mistake, even when that error was forced by the actions of The Sap or his cronies. See here for more on that.

So, who will win? Pfft, I could care less, though The Sap has apparently already claimed he and Kelly destroyed Kirk and Ray. I guess he cares that he may have won against mediocrity. It says something about his level of debate that he can only get the low lying fruit so to speak. But when serious people won't give you the time of day, what's the poor little Sap supposed to do?

Then again, it wouldn't surprise me at all if The Sap defines victory as being, "You didn't convince me in this debate!". Needless to say, such a measurement is worthless for either side, as anyone could make that claim. Or perhaps, "I had a response to everything they said!". As if the success of an argument is only determined by the mere fact of it being uttered. If it turns out that such criteria is behind his claim, being that it's against the C & C boys, it only provides more evidence of how badly the (ir)rationals represent atheism. Recently, in a myspace group, where a discussion about this upcoming debate occurred, an atheist complained that when they do get media exposure it tends to be the (ir)rationals that end up representing them. I responded "If the platypus didn't convince you God has a sense of humor, this should ;-) ".

At least one good thing may come out of this. I've noticed that several subjects make for very good idiot magnets and increase my blog traffic a bit, while also providing entertainment for my rather more sane readers. One subject has been Rosie O'Donnell and her conspiracy lunacy (exhibits 1a, 2a) and the other is when I criticize the (ir)rational response squad (round up here).

I wonder if The Sap will brag about that?

---

Filed under: Religion -- Christianity -- Apologetics

Trackposted to: Outside the Beltway, The Virtuous Republic, Is It Just Me?, Perri Nelson's Website, DragonLady's World, Stuck On Stupid, , The Amboy Times, Leaning Straight Up, Pursuing Holiness, Pet's Garden Blog, Rightlinx, The Magical Rose Garden, third world county, Woman Honor Thyself, Stageleft, stikNstein... has no mercy, The Right Nation, Pirate's Cove, Dumb Ox Daily News, Wake Up America, Right Voices, Right Pundits, Blog @ MoreWhat.com, The Random Yak, A Blog For All, Adam's Blog, The Bullwinkle Blog, Cao's Blog, Phastidio.net, , Conservative Cat, Diary of the Mad Pigeon, Allie Is Wired, The Crazy Rants of Samantha Burns, The World According to Carl, Walls of the City, Blue Star Chronicles, Planck's Constant, The Right Perspective, High Desert Wanderer, OTB Sports, The Yankee Sailor, and Gone Hollywood, thanks to Linkfest Haven Deluxe.

Trackback URI                             Submit this post on Digg.com! width=                     View blog reactions

Tuesday, August 21, 2007

The Rational Response Squad


Or as I like to call them, the (ir)rationals. They're that little hardcore online atheist group consisting of core members Brian Sapient (The Sap), Kelly and Rook Hawkins (Little Rookie). One of their hobbies is pimping the foolish notion that Jesus was just a myth. I've noted their idiocy before, but this latest is rather fun to watch. Apparently another atheist (he isn't the first) had some constructive criticism for them.

A few excerpts:

Until you Rational Responders up your credentials and experience you will continue to come off like the loose change guys: You’re amateur, emotional, and unprofessional.

[...]

Either stop being unprofessional and arrogant or earn the right to be unprofessional and arrogant through life experience or education. Until then you’re making us look bad. (source - thanks to Frank Walton)

Be sure to go through the thread to see the how the (ir)rationals reacted to his posting that letter on their forum. Ah yes, open-minded and free thinkers those (ir)rationals show themselves to be. <- That was sarcasm, for those (ir)rationals groupies who would be confused. I'm willing to bet a penny or two a few may drop by as these posts tend to serve as an idiot magnet, much like my posts about 9-11 conspiracy nuts tend to do.

On a final note, it's rather interesting that an atheist offering criticism of their methods and such also made a 9-11 conspiracy nut comparison. Just say' in.

---

A few elated posts:

Beavis and Butthead vs History
I'm soooo impressed
Rational Response Squad...
How to be publicly stupid 101

---

Filed under: Religion -- Christianity -- 4GrinsNGiggles

Trackposted to: Outside the Beltway, The Virtuous Republic, Perri Nelson's Website, Rosemary's Thoughts, Big Dog's Weblog, Right Truth, Wake Up America, DragonLady's World, Leaning Straight Up, The Amboy Times, Pursuing Holiness, third world county, Wake Up America, Pirate's Cove, The Pink Flamingo, Dumb Ox Daily News, Right Voices, Right Pundits, Blog @ MoreWhat.com, Committees of Correspondence, Nuke's News & Views, Webloggin, The Bullwinkle Blog, , The Florida Masochist, Conservative Cat, Public Domain Clip Art, Diary of the Mad Pigeon, Faultline USA, The Crazy Rants of Samantha Burns, The World According to Carl, Blue Star Chronicles, Planck's Constant, Gulf Coast Hurricane Tracker, High Desert Wanderer, The Yankee Sailor, Gone Hollywood, and OTB Sports, thanks to Linkfest Haven Deluxe.

Trackback URI                             Submit this post on Digg.com! width=                     View blog reactions

Thursday, December 28, 2006

How to be publicly stupid 101


I can imagine the amount of alcohol and blunts necessary to come up with something so shallow and at the same time, so stupid. Then again, these dorks may just be that naturally stupid with their flatulent arrogance.

The Blasphemy Challenge

The Rational Response Squad is giving away 1001 DVDs of The God Who Wasn't There, the hit documentary that the Los Angeles Times calls "provocative -- to put it mildly."

There's only one catch: We want your soul.

It's simple. You record a short message damning yourself to Hell, you upload it to YouTube, and then the Rational Response Squad will send you a free The God Who Wasn't There DVD. It's that easy.
INSTRUCTIONS:

You may damn yourself to Hell however you would like, but somewhere in your video you must say this phrase: "I deny the Holy Spirit."

Why? Because, according to Mark 3:29 in the Holy Bible, "Whoever blasphemes against the Holy Spirit will never be forgiven; he is guilty of an eternal sin." Jesus will forgive you for just about anything, but he won't forgive you for denying the existence of the Holy Spirit. Ever. This is a one-way road you're taking here.

Several problems wit this, which I'll begin explaining with my response to a twit who mentioned it on myspace. I've also dealt with this particular dingledork before, here.

His original post:

Synaptic Chaos wrote:
Anyone on the West coast, check out RRS and BF on the news tonight. The feature will be on the Blasphemy Challenge, which is gaining huge momentum among rational thinkers everywhere.

Check it out:

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=i7QVbJnSPQE

and after I fixed his typos:

Synaptic Chaos wrote:
Anyone on the West coast, check out RRS and BF on the news tonight. The feature will be on the Blasphemy Challenge, which is gaining huge momentum among irrational thinkers, people too cheap to pay for crap scholarship with cheap production values and those who have little understanding of the Bible everywhere.

Check it out:

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=wts-dntnyh4

Just to warn you, the video link I provided has profanity.

Their misunderstanding of this particular passage is dealt with in several ways as there are a couple of views on what the verses mean, within Christianity. One criticism, is that the blasphemy requires first knowing that this is a working of the Holy Spirit, and while denying it, to attribute it to the work of Satan and be an act of apostasy that hardens the heart beyond repentance. Clearly, no one in these videos and by the rules the (ir)rationals have laid out, will run afoul of such criteria.

There is another view of the passage that I ,however, find more preferable. From Tekton Ministries:

Forgiveness in Place - The "Unforgivable Sin" -- and Who Can Be Forgiven (excerpt)

There's been a ton of concern by various parties over this verse in Mark, with some wondering if they have committed this "unpardonable sin" of blaspheming the Holy Ghost, and this is held against the Acts verse by skeptics. But the discussion really warrants no consternation by the believer because the "unpardonable sin" is this and nothing more: UNBELIEF. Thus, there is no contradiction with Acts 13:39 at all, for it sets as a pre-condition, "those who believe" -- and once you believe, you are of course "justified" from your unbelief!

Much more is there, including the testimony of a believer who felt he had committed the unpardonable sin.

One final item to deal with concerning the (ir)rational responders. Brian Sapient, i.e. The Sap, had accused several Christians, myself included, of lying when we criticized their actions over a previous contest they had and that I covered in this post.

The point of dispute being that Christian Cadre, who I referenced in the post, had said that their comments at the (ir)rational's website had been deleted after they had shown the foolishness of their rules for the contest.

It turns out, the (ir)rationals had moved the thread without notification. They said nothing at the Christian Cadre blog about this or at their site until asked, and immediately began calling Christians liars, rather than considering that it was an honest mistake, however, one forced by the (ir)rationals. At best, once it had been made clear that the thread was moved, all they had was a lapse in blog etiquette for the Christian Cadre. They've since updated their blog post concerning this, as you can see here, so the (ir)rationals don't even have that.

Somehow, I just don't see them conceding anything on this matter, judging by how The Sap reacted to an atheist critical of his little group here in the blog comments.

---

Filed under: Religion -- Christianity -- Apologetics -- 4GrinsNGiggles

Trackposted to: Is It Just Me?, Perri Nelson's Website, The Random Yak, Adam's Blog, Don Surber, basil's blog, The Bullwinkle Blog, Jo's Cafe, Conservative Cat, Pursuing Holiness, Rightwing Guy, The HILL Chronicles, third world county, Wake Up America, The Crazy Rants of Samantha Burns, Pirate's Cove, Planck's Constant, Dumb Ox News, High Desert Wanderer, and bRight & Early, thanks to Linkfest Haven Deluxe.

Trackback URI                             Submit this post on Digg.com! width=                     View blog reactions

Sunday, March 25, 2007

It's going to be a busy week


While it would be tempting to make this post about Rosie O'Donnell's 9-11conspiracy lunacy, or the (ir)rational response squad, as both subjects have shown to be quite useful as idiot magnets (exhibits a, b, c) and therefore quite entertaining, I'll do something else. I'm going to be quite busy this next week and doubt I'll be able to post anything so here's a bit more on the Battle of Thermopylae, which was dramatized to great affect in 300 the movie, a film I greatly enjoyed.

The History Channel had a special about the battle, using computer graphics to help illustrate the tactics and events. It's been uploaded to Youtube in three parts.

The Battle Of Thermopylae 1

The Battle Of Thermopylae 2

The Battle Of Thermopylae 3

And to the dork who whined about my not meeting his schedule for approving his inane twaddle regarding 9-11, I probably won't have the ability to approve comments either for the entire week. Sorry, but Karl Rove needs to brief me for my next assignment.

Until I can post again. RAAARRRR!

300-1

My apologies if that caused the French to surrender.

---

Filed under: Movies -- Misc.

Trackposted to: Outside the Beltway, Perri Nelson's Website, The Virtuous Republic, Shadowscope, Stuck On Stupid, The Amboy Times, Pursuing Holiness, third world county, Woman Honor Thyself, Pentimento, stikNstein... has no mercy, The Uncooperative Blogger, Pirate's Cove, LaTogaStrappata®, Right Voices, Right Pundits, Blog @ MoreWhat.com, The Random Yak, Maggie's Notebook, Adam's Blog, basil's blog, Phastidio.net, Cao's Blog, The Bullwinkle Blog, Conservative Cat, Conservative Thoughts, LaTogaStrappata®, sissunchi, Faultline USA, Allie Is Wired, The Crazy Rants of Samantha Burns, The World According to Carl, CORSARI D'ITALIA, High Desert Wanderer, and Gone Hollywood, thanks to Linkfest Haven Deluxe.

Trackback URI                             Submit this post on Digg.com! width=                     View blog reactions

Sunday, May 20, 2007

An angry anti-Christian or stupid is as stupid does


Another addition to my 4GrinsNGiggles department. I received a few compliments for my reply to an individual using the screen name "The Boy (That lives in Darkness)" when he started a thread titled "God doesn't exist". It turns out this  this angry little anti-theist also has the (ir)rational response squad on his friends list. Yes, shocking news that, I never would have expected it, but on to the fun.

His comments in bold

My reply interspersed throughout in regular font (including my typos)

---

okay listen here you hypocritically pieces of trash,

Such a pleasant start

you guys really piss me off,

Really? It was hard to tell from that first line

you bash on gays and yet your leaders rape boys,

are you sure your pissed off? It's hard to tell

you try to get into state to force us non believers to believe,

Might want to adjust your foil beannie

ill tell you why you believe god exists,

This would be more impressive with a drum roll

because you Christians cant comprehend death,

I was wrong, a drum roll wouldn't have helped

when you die there is no pearly gates,

I didnt think there were anyway

just black, nothing more, nothing less.

That's ok, I like the color black

i believe jessus was a good teacher, but a lier.

This jessus fellow remained in a reclined position while teaching?

he had good ideas but you had to build a belief structure around it.

Because believing good ideas is a bad thing?

im not saying you guys are bad, or good

How brave of you

its just that i hate you recruiters,

Seems to me you came here, no one dragged you

let me believe what i belive

That's what God does, so dont complain about the results

---

Filed under: Religion -- Christianity -- 4GrinsNGiggles

Trackposted to: Outside the Beltway, Perri Nelson's Website, Is It Just Me?, Right Truth, Big Dog's Weblog, Leaning Straight Up, The Amboy Times, Pursuing Holiness, third world county, Right Celebrity, Woman Honor Thyself, Wake Up America, Stageleft, , stikNstein... has no mercy, Pirate's Cove, Nuke's news and views, The Pink Flamingo, Dumb Ox Daily News, Right Voices, Blog @ MoreWhat.com, AZAMATTEROFACT, The Random Yak, A Blog For All, guerrilla radio, DeMediacratic Nation, Adam's Blog, Webloggin, The Bullwinkle Blog, Cao's Blog, Phastidio.net, Colloquium, , Jo's Cafe, Conservative Cat, Diary of the Mad Pigeon, The Crazy Rants of Samantha Burns, The World According to Carl, Walls of the City, Blue Star Chronicles, High Desert Wanderer, and The Yankee Sailor, thanks to Linkfest Haven Deluxe.

Trackback URI                             Submit this post on Digg.com! width=                     View blog reactions

Tuesday, September 02, 2008

How to destroy your credibility


And provide a good laugh at the same time.

Every now and then, Shawn Wilkinson gets the urge, for whatever reason, to comment on my blog. His stated motivation does not speak well of himself, but I suppose it would be rather presumptive to not take him at his word.

Spengel's Confusion and Whig Whag Over 1934

I can't help myself. I'm such a masochist that I actually read the writings of idiots for my own self-pleasure. Perhaps its a reflection of my arrogance, or perhaps I have some deep doubt of my own self-confidence and need reassurance that I'm more intelligent compared to the average Joe.

There are three topics that I am knowledgeable in that my masochistic side comes out: historical criticism, global climate studies, and the theory of evolution. These three topics come up with various frequency on my favorite baboon's web log, Mark Sprengel.

Recently, he commented on the recent hub-bub surrounding the 1998 temperature readings. For the full scoop beyond Sprengel's comprehension, read RealClimate's comment.

And don't worry. I expect fully well that everything will continue to fly over Sprengel's head. (I responded in this post)

Considering that I'm politically conservative, with a slight lean to libertarian and also a Christian, it's no wonder that disagreements would arise with someone who has said Dennis Kucinich is his favorite politician and has defended the (ir)Rational Response Squad on several occasions. His saying that Bush, Cheney etc., should be brought up on war crime charges only emphasizes the disparity, while not exhausting the disagreements.

But, little Wilkinson has decided to be so kind as to provide further amusement, while not realizing how badly he's destroying his credibility and his claim to being a non-partisan. Twice now, Shawn has referenced the DailyKos for support. I'll give my readers time to clean up after spewing their food and beverages.

Now that you've recovered and the laughter is reduced to giggling, the first instance of his foolishness would be clumsy ad-homing in an attempt to completely avoid the issue regarding Obama lying about his extreme abortion record. You can see the discussion here, which is better formatted than at the post it's related to here.

But Shawn couldn't stop there. Nope, he has in fact been infected with PDS. Almost immediately, he had two threads in one Myspace group, criticizing Sarah Palin. The hilarity begins with his claiming to be non-partisan but then only gets better when he references DailyKos in another thread. Yep, thread number three. Guess what it was this time.

If you didn't guess, it's the DailyKos baby wasn't Sarah's rumor, which having been deflated very quickly, he tries to cover with Sarah Palin was irresponsible to get on a plane when she was pregnant. You can see his wonderful performance here.

So thank you Shawn, it was entertaining enough to watch your fundie atheist antics and fundie global warming blather, but now you've shown that you'll work with the most ridiculous and extreme on the left, and still call yourself non-partisan. Oh yes, you did use one sentence to take a shot at Obama/Biden when you were called partisan in one of those threads. Tell you what, when you start a few threads criticizing Obama/Biden and you stop offering fallacies and deflections in defense of Obama on my blog, then I'll give you props for non-partisan. That won't remove the DailyKos stain of stupidity and extremism though. So again, thanks for the entertaining demonstration of your descending even further into self-inflicted lunacy than you ever have before.

---

Trackback URI                             Submit this post on Digg.com! width=                     View blog reactions

Saturday, July 08, 2006

If you have to say it so often...


It just might not be true. Have you ever had someone constantly and enthusiastically tell you how smart or honest they are? It isn't uncommon that such constant self-promotion tends to belie a condition rather opposite from what is being so forcefully claimed and actions eventually contradict the self description. Actions speak louder than words after all. A contemporary example would be an internet group calling themselves the "Rational" Response Squad (RRS), and yes, those quotes are intentional and I mean them to be dismissive for good reason, as the reader will soon see.


They've been foolish before with their so called "war" on Easter. As I recall it, they distributed 666 DVDs of a movie titled "The God Who Wasn't There", with the intent of having people place the DVDs in churches so unsuspecting Christians would find them. You can read reviews here and here. For even more fun see this series which engages the war and has some fun with it.


The latest idiocy to issue forth from this often self-proclaimed "rational" goonie squad of atheists consisted of a challenge with several prizes to be awarded.



We are offering a $100 reward and an appearance on our radio show where we will admit we we're wrong to the person who can set a precedent that other important historical figures exist without contemporary evidence. Provide us with the names of five important historical figures that were not written about until at least 25 years after they died (like Jesus).


Their contest also included a first prize of $666 to anyone that could prove to them Jesus existed. They tend to pimp their site in a Christian group on Myspace and this was my response to all the rules they listed for their little challenge:



"Extraordinary claims require extraordinary proof" is nothing but a moving goal post, ill-defined, begging the question and non-objectively applied criteria.


The rules set for this would require that most ancient knowledge of that era be considered invalid.


Hardly surprising that the twits of RRS would be so non-objective with their standards. That they don't see the negative implications for even secular history, only emphasizes their lack of rationality and willfully uninformed condition.


Furthermore, the time from Christ to the NT writings is better than much of ancient history and easily fall within the time frame that disallows legendary embellishment, as established from secular historical data. Paul wrote within 20 years while some were still alive that had seen Jesus after his resurrection, to previously established churches, imploring them to remember what they had already received. He also includes a Christian statement of faith that most date within 3-8 years of the crucifixion.


People need to also remember the strong tradition of oral transmission of data within that culture and that we have examples of students who wrote down the teachings of their rabbis. As such, the NT writings did not just spring forth completely absent from an historical process, but rather, from one with established and proven controls to preserve information and with direct connection to the life and ministry of Christ.


The online apologetics site Christian Cadre, also had some things to say and the closing comments regarding one individual's experience with the "rational" kiddies squad is quite instructive.


Foolishness from the "Rational Responders" in their Jesus Challenge



[...] The “Rational Responders” moderator admitted that they had already lost the contest because they had received more than five figures whose existence was accepted but for whom there was not what they call “contemporary evidence.” Even more submissions were coming in and it is apparent that they were operating out of gross ignorance of the realities of historical studies. The fact is that often our best sources of information about ancient figures and events are ones that were written down after the life of the person described or the events noted therein.


The moderator tried to defend the ignorance of the "Rational Responders" contest by saying they had argued on some discussion boards and no one ever gave them an example before. I think that admission is very revealing. Too many skeptics are so full of themselves or their skepticism that they think that if no one has brought it to their attention then it must not exist. As if the world owes them an obligation to spoon feed them every little factoid that stands in the way of their comfortable skepticism. But participation in select discussion boards is no substitute for actual research and historical knowledge. Anyone with the most basic of knowledge about historical Jesus studies, for example, knows that there are no “contemporary” writings about John the Baptist, but that his existence is undisputed among historians. Yet such examples never occurred to them.


To top it off, the “Rational Responders” apparently thought better of admitting that the entire premise of their challenge to the existence of Jesus had been proven erroneous within hours of announcing their contest. When I checked back later this evening they had deleted our entire discussion. Which, in my book, adds cowardice to ignorance in their vice column.


Despite the limp noodle flop of the their contest and that even some intelligent atheists and skeptics have dismissed them as fundie atheists, I'm willing to bet nothing will change. They'll continue to often claim superior rationality compared to those who believe Christ actually existed and especially against those of us who believe He's the Son of God.


Continuous repetition of a claim, when actions provide contrary evidence, is not much of a sign of rationality, no matter how many "kewl" banner adds try to declare otherwise. Of course it takes courage to admit defeat and error but I'll suggest a small step until they can work up the backbone required. It would only require adding a few letters to their little self-proclamation.


IR





---


Filed under: Apologetics -- Christianity -- Religion


Blogs with open posts: Mudville Gazette -- Jo's Cafe -- The Uncooperative Blogger -- Madman Returns -- third world county -- Blue Star Chronicles -- The Dumb Ox -- Stuck On Stupid -- The Bullwinkle Blog -- THM's Bacon Bits -- The Crazy Rants of Samantha Burns


Technorati Tags: Apologetics -- Christianity -- Religion -- Atheism


Trackback URI                             Submit this post on Digg.com! width=                     View blog reactions

Thursday, July 31, 2008

Capital punishment and stupid Christians


It's hardly surprising that there would be controversy regarding the recent Supreme Court 5-4 Kennedy v. Louisiana ruling that capital punishment could not be used for someone who violently raped a child, while still allowing it for other matters, including treason. While Christians can disagree about whether or not a government should be allowed to use capital punishment, it would help if they kept their arguments reasonable, rather than simply call names.

By this I mean, when someone says they believe the Bible allows for this punishment, a reasonable response from a fellow Christian is not to say only stupid people think the Bible says that. If one is going to so inartfully express their notion that the Bible doesn't support capital punishment, they would do well to explain and support their underlying position, rather than merely act so stupid themselves, by merely calling names. The lack of intellectual engagement is only displayed more clearly if they refuse to do so because they think the Bible does support the death penalty and yet they choose to reject that and deflect from their hypocrisy by childish rhetoric.

It obviously does nothing to support the idea that they actually thought deeply or can discuss this matter honestly, when they also imply that the other person can't possibly have the experiences they've claimed or be directly knowledgeable about the violence and aftermath that others have suffered. Irrational response squad groupies descend to the tactic of calling theists liars quite quickly, in my experience. Why should we think better of Christians when they choose to do the same to other Christians?

Some people also tend to say that when someone explains they support the death penalty for violently raping a child, because they've seen the aftermath of those who were molested or raped, that such is merely an emotional appeal. That would be nearly arguing that having any feeling automatically negates any argument. In fact, noting the damage crime causes and/or that a victim continues to suffer throughout their life, is a necessary component when determining what punishments are necessary and appropriate for many crimes and even civil cases. That one has strong feelings when considering the victim's suffering, indicates they are still human and capable of understanding the hurt others can feel when traumatized. Miscategorizing and denigrating that says nothing positive about the level of humanity of those stooping to such tactics.

As I noted, Christians can have reasonable disagreements about the matter. But those who argue in this fashion indicate they care more for their view and the applause they will receive from others in their choir, or even from those outside the faith, then they do for maintaining unity in the body of Christ.

---

Trackback URI                             Submit this post on Digg.com! width=                     View blog reactions

Thursday, November 29, 2007

Unfinished business and global warming


It's taken me some time to respond to a particular blogger who had something to say about one of my posts. Considering the lack of substance, let alone his missing the point of my article, I really wasn't sure a reply was worth the effort. It didn't help that my eyes ached a bit from rolling them after reading what he had to say. But since I'm bored, and his knee-jerk reaction, arrogance and stupidity make it so easy, I thought I would now address his comments here.

I suppose I could have simply referenced his blather, as it says nothing positive about him on its own, but I tend to lean towards being thorough when I have time and resources. Also, a related exchange occurred after his post, that I include here in my reply, so this post will be longer than usual, hence the click to expand it.

This began with my post, Time travel has actually occurred. Therein, I commented on the changes NASA had to make to US temperature records recently. Did I deny that global warming has occurred? Nope. Did I say it was nothing but a conspiracy? No on that as well. As should be obvious to those with even average reading comprehension and no axe to grind, I emphasized the media hyping 1998 as the hottest year and wondered if they would report with the same enthusiasm, that it no longer was. I also included from the post at HotAir, Allah's comment about how this will hopefully change for the better, the way earth science is reported to the public.

For that, I get the following from Shawn Wilkinson:

Spengel's Confusion and Whig Whag Over 1934

I can't help myself. I'm such a masochist that I actually read the writings of idiots for my own self-pleasure. Perhaps its a reflection of my arrogance, or perhaps I have some deep doubt of my own self-confidence and need reassurance that I'm more intelligent compared to the average Joe.

There are three topics that I am knowledgeable in that my masochistic side comes out: historical criticism, global climate studies, and the theory of evolution. These three topics come up with various frequency on my favorite baboon's web log, Mark Sprengel.

Recently, he commented on the recent hub-bub surrounding the 1998 temperature readings. For the full scoop beyond Sprengel's comprehension, read RealClimate's comment.

And don't worry. I expect fully well that everything will continue to fly over Sprengel's head.

I didn't provide a link, as that's the entire post, and I would rather not reward such foolishness with traffic.

click for more

It's probably obvious that this twit and I have some history, so I'll briefly explain. We've butted heads a few times in several groups on Myspace, mostly over religion. He's an atheist and quite certain of his position despite having his views knocked down a few times by several articles I've referenced from apologetics sites. Such arrogance is typical of the new atheists and he's certainly one of those, having defended the (ir)Rational Response Squad on several occasions. Having seen his Photobucket account I can attest to some of the contents only serving to emphasize his membership in this group of arrogant anti-theists, who far too often think mere rhetoric and "humor" are sufficient arguments against the faith.

I only ran across that post of his because he brought it up in a thread on Myspace, as I haven't bothered to keep track of his blog. It really isn't that interesting to me and it doesn't bother me that he might be disappointed that his apparent ongoing obsession is unrequited. My initial reaction to his latest ejaculation was to show it to some friends and note that I needed more impressive "enemies", to which they agreed. Beyond that and much eye-rolling all around, I didn't see the need to respond to his comments. I later changed my mind when he brought me up in another thread on Myspace, which I had yet to participate in. He decided to respond to someone else's comment in that thread with this:

Ice cores. A true critic at least knows the entirety of the opposition's side. It is the nitwit who grasps onto his position with a complete disregard of learning what he's actually arguing against.

He was oh so clever at bringing me into the discussion by making nitwit a link to my blog. Yes, impressive that. Since I'm a regular in the group, I thought it was about time that I responded to the fool:

*rolls eyes*

True nitwittery is displayed by someone who not only had the point of my blog post about this go over his head, but then popped a blog post out of his ass displaying his own idiocy and then decided to repeat nearly the same here.

As for knowing the entirety of the opposition's side. I don't think you're much of an authority when you toss "your" arguments around about the trial accounts in the NT or try to claim the cosmological argument merely assumes God is uncaused.

He then flippantly replies:

lol! You're referring to the one which I point you in the proper direction of the 1934 tidbit? Sorry if it hurt your feelings to refer you to a more proper source on climatology than your blogosphere circle jerk.

His claim of a more proper source would be RealClimate in his original post, which I'll come back to in a moment. Let's get my reply in that thread out of the way first. His original blather in bold, my reply in regular text.

lol! You're referring to the one which I point you in the proper direction of the 1934 tidbit?

Yes, the one in which my actual point went over your head and apparently still is.

Sorry if it hurt your feelings

Don't flatter yourself. My first reaction was to raise an eyebrow and show some friends and note that I needed more impressive "enemies", to which they agreed. The reaction overall consisted of *rolling eyes*

to refer you to a more proper source on climatology than your blogosphere circle jerk.

Which wasn't very relevant to the point I was making. Do try and pay attention next time you read my blog.

As for circle jerks, that's rather funny coming from the guy who tosses around typical arguments from skeptics.net and Doherty droppings.

I suppose you'll spin your non-response to my other points but what I said still stands regarding your lack of knowledge of the other side's arguments, either that, or you just spin them to attack straw men.

And now what of this, as he claims, proper source? I'll refer to Steve McIntyre's comments concerning that. An excerpt from his blog:

In less hysterical tones over at realclimate, Hansen’s colleague and NASA spokesman, Gavin Schmidt, has also minimized the error:

Another week, another ado over nothing.

…

Sum total of this change? A couple of hundredths of degrees in the US rankings …

NASA spokesman [Gavin] Schmidt also went to the trouble of misrepresenting my role in identifying the specific error. Both at the blog and in my email to Hansen, I specifically identified the error as probably coming from use of one USHCN version prior to 2000 and another version for 2000 and later - a diagnosis confirmed by NASA. Unwilling to even concede me this gruel, Schmidt denied that I even “speculated” as to the cause of the error”

Steve M pointed out where the error came from in his blog posts and his email notifying GISS of the problem. The GISS people simply confirmed that he was correct.

[Response: Not so. He saw the jump but did not speculate as to the cause. - gavin] (source)

He goes into more detail regarding the downplay of this matter compared to how it was treated in the past. Be sure to read it all and keep his blog in mind on the global warming issue. A more recent post on the matter here is also interesting. He isn't extreme on the issue, from what I can see, and really is trying to make sure we're working with accurate data when making such potentially huge decisions regarding public policy.

As for circle jerk, it's rather interesting while attacking me for that, this kid referenced a source that's a colleague of the scientist who's data was in error (nice circle there) and also happens to be a NASA spokesman. That last point further illustrates the shallow thinking of Shawn Wilkinson. If he had only taken the time, he could have clicked on the link to HotAir in my post and read this:

That said, there were people within NASA’s earth science groups like Dr. Michael King who said that they found the agenda-driven science frustrating, an in particular the effect that overzealous public affairs officers were having on the way the science was being reported to the press. In one story relayed during a meeting I attended at Goddard in 2005, several of the scientists and visualizers talked about public affairs reporting on some Landsat (iirc it was Landsat) imagery of Mt. Kilimanjaro and its icecap. The satellite photos showed the moutain’s ice cap receeding due to seasonal change; public affairs reported the photos as evidence that global warming was causing the ice cap’s retreat. Public affairs was hyping the stories to the press, which in turn added even more hype. The public has been getting earth science reporting that’s hyped, squared.

McIntyre also has an excellent essay, here, concerning due diligence and disclosure in the climate science field.

Taking all this into account, I have some additions to the original misguided comments criticizing my post, to make it a bit more accurate. My improvements in bold.

In a rare moment of honesty Shawn Wilkinson says:

I can't help myself. I'm such a masochist that I actually read the writings of idiots for my own self-pleasure. Of course by this I mean my own blog, The Natural Skeptic. Perhaps its definitely a reflection of my arrogance and ignorance, or perhaps I have some deep doubt of my own self-confidence and need faux reassurance that I'm more intelligent compared to the average Joe. Unfortunately, I've failed again, only proving that I'm still just an arrogant fool. My only recourse is to continue with chest beating rhetoric and hope nobody actually notices.

Finally, his additional stupidity was to think that when I said "enemies" I meant that literally or that I was commenting on his view of me. I think most people understand my use of quotation marks there and that my view of this individual is merely dismissive, and for good reason.

Ah the Internet. Ain't it wonderful, the special people we can run up against?

roll it up

---

Filed under: NewsPolitics -- Misc. -- 4GrinsNGiggles

Trackposted to: Outside the Beltway, Blog @ MoreWhat.com, The Virtuous Republic, Perri Nelson's Website, Rosemary's Thoughts, guerrilla radio, Right Truth, Adam's Blog, Leaning Straight Up, The Bullwinkle Blog, Big Dog's Weblog, Cao's Blog, The Amboy Times, Chuck Adkins, Conservative Cat, Pursuing Holiness, Allie is Wired, third world county, The Crazy Rants of Samantha Burns, The World According to Carl, Pirate's Cove, Blue Star Chronicles, The Pink Flamingo, Republican National Convention Blog, Dumb Ox Daily News, High Desert Wanderer, Right Voices, and The Yankee Sailor, thanks to Linkfest Haven Deluxe.

Trackback URI                             Submit this post on Digg.com! width=                     View blog reactions

Monday, February 23, 2009

Does God Exist?


A well known Atheist and a Christian apologist are scheduled to debate the question later this year.

Christopher Hitchens will be on the side of Atheism and Dr. William Lane Craig will be arguing that God does exist.

The debate will be hosted at Biola University Saturday, April 4 at 7:30 PM.

Christopher Hitchens vs. William Lane Craig, Ph.D., D.Theol.

Moderated by Hugh Hewitt and hosted by Craig Hazen
Cosponsored with Biola Associated Students
Book signing to follow

Considering the background of both participants this debate should be quite interesting. This debate has the potential for much more intellectual exercise than the Cameron/Comfort vs the (ir)rational response squad duo that had me merely yawning in anticipation. I would love to attend but unfortunately Southern California is too far a trip at this time. I’m sure transcripts, at the very least, will be available eventually, perhaps even video.

Even if you can’t make it, spread the word. Reasoned debate between two adversaries, with no quarter drawn, and concerning such an important matter, is a shame to miss simply because one wasn’t aware of the event.

---

Trackback URI                             Submit this post on Digg.com! width=                     View blog reactions

Friday, February 02, 2007

Dialogue with RRS groupies - round 1


Apparently, some didn't like my last post, and perhaps previous posts as well, regarding the (ir)Rational Response Squad. The comments and replies were getting rather too long so, I'll bring it up the post level.

Per my usual, the original comments from the RRS groupie are in bold, with my replies in regular font, interspersed throughout. You can see the comments by "Wank Falton" in original form here.

Or in your case, one ends up being a tool. High five!

*yawn*

And who are you to know the ultimate biddings of said supposed god? Who made you the soothsayer of the supernatural?

Perhaps you might consider Christian doctrine as developed over several thousand years from experience and the Bible? Online "contradictions" lists don't count.

Please, please, PLEASE! show us the evidence which is right in front of us. Pleeeeeease, I beg you.

Go fish. It's not like the information is difficult to find in this day and age. Your attitude shows that you've already determined none exists, which is typical of the (ir)rationals and their groupies. I see no reason to waste my time providing the fish myself, so to speak.

And you can't say bible - that would be strike one - that isn't evidence of the supernatural. Believing that would be intellectually dishonest now, wouldn't it.

You assume, and foolishly so, that I would argue in circular fashion. Your immediate jump to such also demonstrates your deep-seated bias. Properly used, I see no reason to automatically dismiss the data within the Bible.

And for someone who supposedly wants to partake in "robust discussion" you like to stoop to levels of name calling and childish playground chatter...The Sap? That's r-tarded mate.

Well mate, if I accept your criteria, then I must conclude the same for you, considering your play on Frank Walton's name and blog. However, I've had previous experience with The Sap, and because of this I know he is not interested in reasonable discussion. As such, I see no reason to bother with avoiding sarcasm. Also, would you prefer that I called him a viper, serpent, say his father is the devil? You might want to think about that before you say it wouldn't be "Christ like".

Finally, I've had plenty of discussions with people ranging from Muslim, pagan, atheist, agnostic and deist. While I'll debate aggressively, I can be reasonable with those who are also reasonable.

---

There's more but I wanted to break the comments out per groupie.

---

Filed under: Religion -- Christianity -- Apologetics

Trackposted to: Outside the Beltway, Perri Nelson's Website, Is It Just Me?, Big Dog's Weblog, Right Truth, Shadowscope, Stuck On Stupid, Common Folk Using Common Sense, Thought Alarm, The Amboy Times, Maggie's Notebook | Conservative Blog, Pursuing Holiness, Sujet- Celebrities, The HILL Chronicles, third world county, Right Celebrity, Woman Honor Thyself, stikNstein... has no mercy, Pirate's Cove, The Right Nation, The Pink Flamingo, Renaissance Blogger, Right Voices, Right Pundits, A Blog For All, The Random Yak, Adam's Blog, basil's blog, Phastidio.net, The Bullwinkle Blog, Cao's Blog, Jo's Cafe, Conservative Cat, Thought Alarm: And the Truth Shall Set You Free (If It's Not Supressed), Diary of the Mad Pigeon, Faultline USA, The Crazy Rants of Samantha Burns, Blue Star Chronicles, High Desert Wanderer, and Gone Hollywood, thanks to Linkfest Haven Deluxe.

Technorati tags: -- -- -- -- --
Trackback URI                             Submit this post on Digg.com! width=                     View blog reactions

Tuesday, February 13, 2007

And I thought the teeny boppers were stupid


At least they have an excuse, being that they're young. Perhaps they'll eventually study a few things rather than continue to uncritically accept what they threw around in their little youtube video that I addressed in a previous post. However, there are others, smug in their rejection of God or any thing supernatural, who unless they're simply an uneducated toddler, have no excuse while being unable to see the absolute foolishness of what they say.

I've had a bit of dialogue of late with several (ir)rationals groupies here on my blog. Considering my experience with this type before, I don't normally rush to provide extensive answers. Those who proudly strut in their extreme skepticism, while applying it inconsistently are clearly not interested in reasoned discussion. There's really not much else to think of someone who says there's no evidence whatsoever for the Christian faith or even for the supernatural.

If you want to start from the beginning, the post that started all of this and the various exchanges that followed:

Rational Response Squad...
Dialogue with RRS groupies - round 1
Dialogue with RRS groupies - round 2
(ir)Rational Responders - dialogue with groupie 2 cont.

Little Pirate's rather pathetic reply to that last post:

Obviously, you're unable to assimilate an atheists stimulating concepts into your blighted and retarded world-view. I don't know what your problem is, but I'll bet it's hard to pronounce.

Have fun with your overpopulated, banner-laden, 1995'esque blog

Atheists for Jesus!

and my reply:

Little Pirate,

Thanks for proving the waste of time that it is to offer substantive data and arguments to a head up their ass skeptic.

---

Little Pirate has since replied again, though in more wordy fashion, however, it will soon be clear that the increased volume of text does nothing to rise above the previous shallow and uninformed replies that this particular groupie is so capable of.

Little Pirate: bold font

My replies interspersed throughout: italic font

---

Big Mark,

Just remember you're the one who set the tone for the commentary on this blog with your original post...I'm just following your lead.

How cute, now you're saying "you did it first!" Actually, what I did in my first post was note what I saw as flaws in a news report concerning the (ir)rationals and then stated that I didn't care to rush into taking the time to present things to hardcore skeptics as you and others immediately demonstrated being. You've only proceeded to confirm my original perception and this reply does nothing to reverse that. For your little, "just following your lead" to really work, you would have to actually have offered substance that I just dismissed out of hand. That's not what happened, as I replied to your little article from John Loftus with explanations and sources as to why he was wrong on so many issues. I notice you have yet to bother replying to any of the points raised, even in your second reply to that post.

Either way, the fact is that you have yet to defend your religious beliefs on a rational basis - even when I asked you a simple question.

You either have a problem with reading comprehension or didn't bother to actually read the post that you have now replied to - twice.

It's easy to say hey, look at the Bible, the evidence is obvious (to which you did).

Actually, I did not. While my answers were brief, I offered more explanation than - because the Bible says.

But if you seriously look at the "evidence" for believing in a supreme being, the evidence is not really evidence at all - it's just a bunch of weak arguments rolled up in a variety of talking points.

Wow, such a detailed refutation of all the various arguments for the supernatural. <-- sarcasm, as I'm sure it went over your head.

Evidence against believing in a supreme being is so much more substantial, verifiable, reproduceable and gratifying, and it is mounting every day.

And again, since you obviously didn't read my previous post, go read what Paul Davies has written or take the time to look up Antony Flew. The situation is certainly not as you portray it, unless you think Christianity is only young earth creationism and hyper literal understandings of the Biblical text. If that's your entire understanding of the faith, then you only demonstrate your ignorance, let alone, your apparent claim of a negative being proved.

If your religious beliefs comfort you, or you genuinely believe in them, that's your prerogative - but neither of those things give credence to your supernatural beliefs being true. Not a single one.

It's not like I argued for feelings or sincerity as evidence. Do you ever pay attention?

I choose a natural world-view because it makes more sense, and there is evidence to support it.

Except the Johny Loftus article you presented as sooo rational, was filled with ignorance and poorly supported conclusions. Also, while there is evidence that life adapts, that is quite different from ultimate origins, as well as, the problem of a completely natural world-view explaining how rationality can be valid if everything is merely the result of non-rational motions of atomic particles.

In the 30+ years I was a follower of the Christian faith, I never once was provided evidence to support what I was suppose to believe. I just had to believe because "it was the truth" - that's how I was raised.

That only shows you were a stupid Christian surrounded by too many using the "blind faith" crutch that I care little for. Hardly surprising since you're also a stupid atheist.

But I've broken free from the mindtrap that is religion - and it's a great thing. If verifiable evidence turns up to support to existence of a supernatural being, I'm willing to consider the possibility of the existence of a god/gods. Until then, that blighted world-view doesn't interest me.

*yawn* Keep strutting oh peacocky one. You've only shown that you haven't bothered to look into the information I've already presented or even deal with the points I've raised. You haven't really broken away from any mindtrap when you maintained your condition of being willfully uninformed, regardless of your change in world view.

"It is far better to grasp the universe as it really is than to persist in delusion, however satisfying and reassuring."
- Carl Sagan

I see no reason to disagree with Sagan on that. I have reason to draw different conclusions regarding the universe as it really is though.

---

Concluding comments:

For someone who is observant enough to comment on the style of my blog, it's rather telling that they miss seeing that I have an Apologetics Department/Category in the left sidebar and a search feature in the right, as well as also in the blogger bar at the top. I also have several links to apologetics resources in my left sidebar. Talk about selective vision, with not a single point in my previous post actually being addressed and the various means to seek out further information, also completely ignored.

Such a determined effort to not even reply to brief explanations and points raised or seek further information is not the sign of one who is actually open to evidence as this (ir)rationals groupie claimed to be. As to formerly being a Christian, big whoop, clearly not a very informed one, to say the least, and very determined to maintain that condition of being uninformed.

Those so proud of their apostasy sadly confirm scripture.

Heb 6:4 For it is impossible for those who were once enlightened, and have tasted of the heavenly gift, and were made partakers of the Holy Ghost,
Heb 6:5 And have tasted the good word of God, and the powers of the world to come,
Heb 6:6 If they shall fall away, to renew them again unto repentance; seeing they crucify to themselves the Son of God afresh, and put him to an open shame.

Hopefully, it isn't too late for those bragging about their turning from the faith. But though that may unfortunately be the case, we can still learn from this. We apparently have an example of what relying on the crutch of "blind faith" can lead to. We not only perform a disservice to ourselves when we do so, but we only help undermine others in the faith and bear some responsibility for those who turn away, thinking there is no evidence whatsoever. However, that they choose to remain so uninformed, when the situation is easily resolved, means they still bear final responsibility regarding their condition. While it's more difficult, to study and provide good answers, it is encouraged in scripture and it will bring great rewards.

2Ti 2:15 Study to show thyself approved unto God, a workman that needeth not to be ashamed, rightly dividing the word of truth.

---

Filed under: Religion -- Christianity -- Apologetics

Trackposted to: Outside the Beltway, Random Dreamer, Perri Nelson's Website, Is It Just Me?, The Random Yak, Big Dog's Weblog, Adam's Blog, basil's blog, DragonLady's World, Common Folk Using Common Sense, The Bullwinkle Blog, The Amboy Times, Conservative Cat, Conservative Thoughts, Pursuing Holiness, Wake Up America, Rightlinx, Faultline USA, third world county, stikNstein... has no mercy, Blue Star Chronicles, Pirate's Cove, Planck's Constant, Dumb Ox Daily News, High Desert Wanderer, and Right Voices, thanks to Linkfest Haven Deluxe.

Trackback URI                             Submit this post on Digg.com! width=                     View blog reactions









Choose your language:
Francais/French Deutsch/German Italiano/Italian Portugues/Portuguese
Espanol/Spanish 日本語/Japanese 한국어/Korean 中文(简体)/Chinese Simplified

Creative Commons License


As defined and limited by the license, any use of work from this blog, must be attributed to Mark K. Sprengel and include a link back to this blog.




Get updates by e-mail:

Delivered by FeedBurner

Widgetize! Subscribe Social Bookmark Blogs that link here
My Technorati profile


Also, follow me on Twitter

Search this blog:

powered by Aditya


Recent Comments: